Fairhaven Mennonite Church (Myerstown, Pennsylvania, USA)

Jump to navigation Jump to search
Fairhaven Mennonite Church, 2013.
Photo by Merle Gingrich.

The Fairhaven Mennonite Church in Myerstown, Pennsylvania, USA, was born in a meeting held on 21 May 1973 by a group who desired to form a new Mennonite congregation under the leadership of Homer Bomberger. The families in this group were primarily from the Bernville and Texter Mountain Mennonite churches which had become part of the Eastern Pennsylvania Mennonite Church (EPMC) when it separated from the Lancaster Mennonite Conference in 1968.

Three men were appointed as trustees for the group; their first assignment was to locate a building in which the group could worship. They learned the old, vacant Brethren building in Myerstown was for sale and agreed to purchase it for $19,000. The new congregation was the second to be established in what would later become the Mid-Atlantic Mennonite Fellowship (MAMF).

Twenty-six people attended the first Sunday morning service of the Fairhaven Mennonite Church on 3 June 1973. The first communion service was conducted by Homer Bomberger and held 11 November 1973. Attendance at this service was 58. A dedication service was held on 25 November 1973.

Eli Burkholder was the first ordained leader to serve at Fairhaven. He had been ordained as deacon on 30 August 1955, at the Texter Mountain Mennonite Church (Lancaster Conference) and was given charge as deacon at Fairhaven on 18 July 1973. Visiting and retired ministers from other churches were used until Fairhaven had a full ministerial team.

Daniel Horning came to Fairhaven from Elm Street, Lebanon (EPMC), as an ordained deacon. He was given charge on 5 October 1974, to assist Deacon Eli Burkholder, and then ordained as Fairhaven's first minister on 8 February 1975. Amos Martin, who had been ordained as minister at the Meckville Mennonite Church (Lancaster Mennonite Conference) and served as minister at the Rehrersburg Mennonite Church (EPMC) from 1968-1976, transferred to Fairhaven. He was given charge as minister on 9 October 1976. Eli Burkholder died suddenly on 10 November 1976. Harry Martin was ordained as deacon on 4 June 1977, to fill the vacancy. He was the first person to be ordained from within the congregation.

The church building was constructed by the Church of the Brethren in 1876. They had remodeled the building several times before constructing a new facility nearby in 1971. The old building was in need of many repairs. Fairhaven made the first improvement to the building on 16 June 1973, when the rose pink walls of the auditorium were painted a mint green. The antique blue wool carpet in the aisles was removed in 1984 and replaced with wall-to-wall tan carpet. Many other improvements were made through the years, including a major overhaul of the basement and kitchen in 1988. The house beside the church had been owned and used by the Brethren as a parsonage. In 1976 they decided to sell the house and gave the Fairhaven congregation the opportunity to buy it privately. On 12 May 1976 the congregation voted to purchase the house. After being rented to various families for more than 30 years, it was dismantled in 2014 to construct an addition to the church intended to provide more classrooms and a more accessible entrance.

Fairhaven has always been a service-oriented congregation with many of its members serving in various ways in the local community and foreign missions. Several members have gone on to be career missionaries. The excellent acoustics in the church sanctuary make it an ideal place for the youth in the Joyful Hearts Chorus to hold practice sessions.

In Fairhaven's 40-year history, the congregation has been served by bishops Homer Bomberger, Aaron Bowman, Joe Rudolph, and Bernell Burkholder Sr. Those who served as ministers are: Daniel Horning, Amos Martin, Joe Rudolph, Amos Weaver, Bernell Burkholder Sr., Merle Gingrich, and Matt Martin. Deacons included Eli Burkholder, Daniel Horning, Harry Martin, and Gerald Martin.

In 2013, the ministerial team consisted of Bernell Burkholder, bishop; Merle Gingrich and Matt Martin, ministers; and Gerald Martin, deacon. Amos Weaver (minister) and Harry Martin (deacon) are retired.

As of 1 January 2013, Fairhaven had 114 members.


Stauffer, Romaine, ed. Mid-Atlantic Mennonite Fellowship 1972-2013. Myerstown, Pa.: Little Mountain Printing, 2014.

Additional Information

Address: 801 S. Railroad Street, Myerstown, Pa. 17067

Phone: (717) 866-7811


Denominational Affiliations: Mid-Atlantic Mennonite Fellowship

Fairhaven Mennonite Church Pastors

Name Years
of Service
Daniel Horning 1974-1980
Amos Martin 1982-1992
Joseph Rudolph 1982-1993
Amos Weaver 1986-2012
Bernell Burkholder 1991-present
Merle Gingrich 1996-present
Matthew Martin 2005-present


Map:Fairhaven Mennonite Church (Myerstown, Pennsylvania, USA)

Author(s) Romaine Stauffer
Date Published April 2014

Cite This Article

MLA style

Stauffer, Romaine. "Fairhaven Mennonite Church (Myerstown, Pennsylvania, USA)." Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. April 2014. Web. 20 May 2022. https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Fairhaven_Mennonite_Church_(Myerstown,_Pennsylvania,_USA)&oldid=121807.

APA style

Stauffer, Romaine. (April 2014). Fairhaven Mennonite Church (Myerstown, Pennsylvania, USA). Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. Retrieved 20 May 2022, from https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Fairhaven_Mennonite_Church_(Myerstown,_Pennsylvania,_USA)&oldid=121807.

©1996-2022 by the Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. All rights reserved.