Akron Mennonite Church (Akron, Pennsylvania, USA)

Jump to navigation Jump to search

Akron Mennonite Church (AMC) in Akron, Pennsylvania, celebrated its 50th anniversary in 2009. It began in October 1959 when a group of 89 adults and children gathered in a fire hall in nearby Brownstown for a worship service with the intent to found a church that would serve the community where many of them lived and worked. The congregation began with the blessing of its mother church, Monterey Mennonite Church, now Forest Hills Mennonite Church.

About half of the founding group were not native to Lancaster County, Pennsylvania. They came from other parts of the United States and Canada to work with Mennonite Central Committee (MCC). Many had been overseas as missionaries or part of the Pax program, an alternative to military service. Others had come from Civilian Public Service camps. Monterey had been a safe haven for these outsiders, who did not fit comfortably in the Lancaster Mennonite Conference churches because of lifestyle differences, including the way they dressed.

Glenn Esh, pastor of the Monterey congregation, served as part-time pastor for AMC until Kermit Derstine was called in August 1961. The Brownstown fire hall was the congregation’s home for three-and-a-half years, until they could build a church.

Of the 89 who had gathered for that first service, 46 became charter members on 8 May 1960. The congregation was affiliated with the Ohio and Eastern Conference of the Mennonite Church until the formation of the Atlantic Coast Conference. Later they established dual denominational membership, joining the General Conference Mennonite Church.

In 1977, a small group of members left the Akron congregation, with its blessing, to start Pilgrims Mennonite Church, also meeting in Akron, offering a loose church structure with no paid leadership. Pilgrims joined the Lancaster Mennonite Conference.

Another group of 26 members and their children left in 1985, with Akron’s blessing, to form a church in the city of Lancaster. Community Mennonite Church of Lancaster chose to affiliate with the Atlantic Coast Conference, as well as General Conference. They have experienced significant growth and in 2009 held two worship services each Sunday.

This church plant briefly relieved AMC’s space issue, but after long and controversial discussions, the congregation in 1987 began building a 500-seat sanctuary, with additional office and classroom space. The building was dedicated in 1989. This was a major step for members whose priority had been contributing money to "people causes" rather than to building.

AMC has been a diverse congregation. Peace and justice themes have been a beacon to its members. It has provided an environment that welcomes questions and resists easy answers. The AMC position on women in leadership was a positive factor in attracting new members. The strong connection to MCC offered a broad worldview and an expanded awareness of global needs. At any given time, congregational members have served with MCC or various church programs in other countries.

Beyond the MCC connection, AMC has included people from diverse walks of life in the business and professional world. Members have served on the boards of international agencies, and headed church and secular organizations. AMC members played an active role in the merger of the Mennonite Church and the General Conference Mennonite Church to form Mennonite Church USA.

Akron Mennonite began with a mission to be a light in the community, and throughout these years it has continued to serve the community. Members serve in volunteer positions, are active in helping community folks in need, and support a day-care center in the educational wing. This program began in the 1960s and has expanded to an accredited preschool center with more than one hundred children enrolled.


Kaufman, Gerald W. Pilgrims on a journey : Akron Mennonite Church, 1959-2009 : a social history. Akron, Pa. : Akron Mennonite Church, 2009.

Additional Information

Address: 1311 Diamond Street, Akron, Pennsylvania

Phone: 717-859-1488

Website: Akron Mennonite Church

Denominational Affiliations:

Atlantic Coast Conference

Mennonite Church USA

Akron Mennonite Church Pastors

Name Years
of Service
Glenn Esh 1959-1961
Kermit Destine     1961-1968
Don Blosser 1969-1976
Truman Brunk 1977-1985
Beryl Jantzi, Youth 1982-1986
Urbane Peachey 1986-2000
Fred Swartzentruber 1987-1989
Beryl Jantzi 1991-1996
Dawn Yoder Harms 1997-2009
Jim S. Amstutz 2001-2015
Michelle J. Dula 2011-2015
Rachel S. Nolt 2017-present
Matthew A. Carlson 2019-present

Akron Mennonite Church Membership

Year Members
1960 46
1965 119
1970 180
1975 237
1980 293
1985 345
1990 347
1995 388
2000 414
2005 453
2008 466
2020 463

AMC has had  a "revolving door membership." In addition to covenant commitment members, there have been associate members who chose to keep their membership in their home church, while actively participating in AMC's church life. Others chose to join while they were here with MCC or another short-term assignment. Some youth who left for college and jobs elsewhere maintained their membership at AMC. Many who still lived in the community no longer attended AMC. With a 2009 membership list at 466, there was an average attendance of 250 on Sunday morning, including visitors and children. The average age of members was increasing while AMC attracted fewer young families. A study began in 2009 to assess needs and staff configuration to best serve the congregation’s needs.


Map:Akron Mennonite Church (Akron, Pennsylvania)

Author(s) Gerald W Kaufman
Date Published July 2019

Cite This Article

MLA style

Kaufman, Gerald W. "Akron Mennonite Church (Akron, Pennsylvania, USA)." Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. July 2019. Web. 5 Dec 2023. https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Akron_Mennonite_Church_(Akron,_Pennsylvania,_USA)&oldid=177070.

APA style

Kaufman, Gerald W. (July 2019). Akron Mennonite Church (Akron, Pennsylvania, USA). Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. Retrieved 5 December 2023, from https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Akron_Mennonite_Church_(Akron,_Pennsylvania,_USA)&oldid=177070.

©1996-2023 by the Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. All rights reserved.