Difference between revisions of "Feetwashing"

From GAMEO
Jump to navigation Jump to search
[checked revision][checked revision]
m
Line 3: Line 3:
 
Feetwashing, also called the "washing of the saints' feet," was in the 1950s observed as an ordinance by most Mennonites in the world. It was customarily based on the express command and example of Jesus, who washed His disciples' feet at the Last Supper (John 13:1-17), and on the statement by Paul (1 Timothy 5:9, 10) that having washed the saints' feet was a qualification for a widow's acceptance into the church widows' group. Rarely has the Old Testament practice of washing the feet of visitors as an act of hospitality toward strangers (Genesis 18:4; Genesis 19:2; Genesis 24:32; Genesis 43:24; Judges 19:21; 1 Samuel 25:40, 41) been used to support the practice, except in the early days in Holland, when the practice in some groups was limited to washing the feet of visiting elders and ministers or even of laymen as a sign of affectionate recognition. The most common practice has been and still is to observe the ordinance immediately following the [[Communion|communion]] service. In the [[Franconia Mennonite Conference (Mennonite Church USA)|Franconia Conference]] of the [[Mennonite Church (MC)|Mennonite Church (MC)]], where the ordinance was long out of practice, it was observed at the preparatory service on the day preceding communion. Since most congregations that observed it in the 1950s celebrated the communion twice a year, in the spring and fall, feetwashing also came twice a year.
 
Feetwashing, also called the "washing of the saints' feet," was in the 1950s observed as an ordinance by most Mennonites in the world. It was customarily based on the express command and example of Jesus, who washed His disciples' feet at the Last Supper (John 13:1-17), and on the statement by Paul (1 Timothy 5:9, 10) that having washed the saints' feet was a qualification for a widow's acceptance into the church widows' group. Rarely has the Old Testament practice of washing the feet of visitors as an act of hospitality toward strangers (Genesis 18:4; Genesis 19:2; Genesis 24:32; Genesis 43:24; Judges 19:21; 1 Samuel 25:40, 41) been used to support the practice, except in the early days in Holland, when the practice in some groups was limited to washing the feet of visiting elders and ministers or even of laymen as a sign of affectionate recognition. The most common practice has been and still is to observe the ordinance immediately following the [[Communion|communion]] service. In the [[Franconia Mennonite Conference (Mennonite Church USA)|Franconia Conference]] of the [[Mennonite Church (MC)|Mennonite Church (MC)]], where the ordinance was long out of practice, it was observed at the preparatory service on the day preceding communion. Since most congregations that observed it in the 1950s celebrated the communion twice a year, in the spring and fall, feetwashing also came twice a year.
  
[[File:HM10-20-53.jpg|300px|thumb|right|''Feetwashing. MAO
+
[[File:HM10-20-53.jpg|300px|thumb|right|''Feetwashing.<br />
 +
Source: Mennonite Archives of Ontario slide collection'']]
  
slide collection'']]    The most common mode of the observance is as follows: After the communion service is completed, one of the ministers or deacons reads and comments on John 13:1-17. Basins, usually small wooden or metal tubs, with warm water and towels have meanwhile been provided in sufficient quantity to permit a fairly rapid observance. These are placed, either in the front of the church or in the "amen" corners, and in the "ante-rooms," or in some cases in the rows between the benches. The sexes then wash (more properly rinse or lightly touch with water) feet separately in pairs, concluding with the greeting of the [[Kiss, Holy|holy kiss]] and a "God bless you." In some localities towels are furnished in the form of short aprons to be tied by cords around the waist, in presumed imitation of Jesus "girding himself," though most commonly ordinary towels are used. In some congregations the practice is not pair-washing but rowwashing, in which case each person washes the feet of his right-hand neighbor in turn in a continuous chain ([[United Missionary Church|United Missionary Church]], some General Conference Mennonite congregations). In the Church of God in Christ Mennonite group the ministers wash each other's feet first, and then wash the feet of all the brethren in turn, the ministers' wives doing the same for the sisters.
+
The most common mode of the observance is as follows: After the communion service is completed, one of the ministers or deacons reads and comments on John 13:1-17. Basins, usually small wooden or metal tubs, with warm water and towels have meanwhile been provided in sufficient quantity to permit a fairly rapid observance. These are placed, either in the front of the church or in the "amen" corners, and in the "ante-rooms," or in some cases in the rows between the benches. The sexes then wash (more properly rinse or lightly touch with water) feet separately in pairs, concluding with the greeting of the [[Kiss, Holy|holy kiss]] and a "God bless you." In some localities towels are furnished in the form of short aprons to be tied by cords around the waist, in presumed imitation of Jesus "girding himself," though most commonly ordinary towels are used. In some congregations the practice is not pair-washing but rowwashing, in which case each person washes the feet of his right-hand neighbor in turn in a continuous chain ([[United Missionary Church|United Missionary Church]], some General Conference Mennonite congregations). In the Church of God in Christ Mennonite group the ministers wash each other's feet first, and then wash the feet of all the brethren in turn, the ministers' wives doing the same for the sisters.
  
 
Although the interpretation of the ordinance may vary, it is always held to be symbolical of a spiritual lesson, and is never considered to have any religious value per se, or to be a "good work." The most common interpretation is that it teaches humility and equality. Often the lesson of service is included along with the other meanings. In some instances it has been and is observed as a symbol of the daily sanctification which is needed by the Christian as he comes into contact with sin and temptation.
 
Although the interpretation of the ordinance may vary, it is always held to be symbolical of a spiritual lesson, and is never considered to have any religious value per se, or to be a "good work." The most common interpretation is that it teaches humility and equality. Often the lesson of service is included along with the other meanings. In some instances it has been and is observed as a symbol of the daily sanctification which is needed by the Christian as he comes into contact with sin and temptation.
  
Among the North American Mennonite groups the observance varies. The following groups practiced it universally in the 1950s, following the communion service: Mennonite Church (MC), [[Conservative Mennonite Conference|Conservative Mennonite Church]], Old Order [[Amish|Amish]], [[Fellowship of Evangelical Churches|Evangelical Mennonites]], [[Evangelical Mennonite Conference (Kleine Gemeinde)|Evangelical Mennonites]] ([[Kleine Gemeinde|Kleine Gemeinde]]), [[Reformed Mennonite Church|Reformed Mennonites]], [[Mennonite Brethren in Christ|Mennonite Brethren in Christ]], [[United Missionary Church|United Missionary Church]], [[Krimmer Mennonite Brethren Publications Committee|Krimmer Mennonite Brethren]], [[Church of God in Christ, Mennonite (CGC)|Church of God in Christ Mennonites]]. Among the acculturated groups, the practice has declined since the 1950s. The [[Mennonite Brethren Church|Mennonite Brethren]] formerly universally observed the ordinance, but  in the [[United States of America|United States]] in the 1950s the number was 85-90 percent of the congregations, while in [[Canada|Canada]] only a minority do so. Among the General Conference Mennonites only a small minority of the congregations practice feetwashing, depending upon the background of each congregation. A study by [[Pannabecker, Samuel Floyd (1896-1977)|S. F. Pannabecker]] in 1929 showed that of 107 [[General Conference Mennonite Church (GCM)|General Conference Mennonites]] congregations in the United States, 23 encouraged it. Of the 23, the [[Western District Conference (Mennonite Church USA)|Western District]] had 10, the [[Northern District Conference (General Conference Mennonite Church)|Northern District]] 8. Since then the number has decreased. An official conference study in 1943 showed that then 9 congregations made it obligatory, while 14 encouraged it. The Evangelical Mennonite Brethren, who formerly practiced it universally, have almost completely dropped it. The [[Lower Skippack Mennonite Church (Skippack, Pennsylvania, USA)|Lower Skippack Mennonite Church]] ([[Johnson Mennonites|Johnson Mennonite]]) withdrew from the [[Eastern District Conference (Mennonite Church USA)|Eastern District]] Conference (GCM) in 1861 because it observed feetwashing, while the conference refused to make it mandatory. The Evangelical Mennonites and the Mennonite Brethren in Fernheim Colony, Paraguay, also practice feetwashing.
+
Among the North American Mennonite groups the observance varies. The following groups practiced it universally in the 1950s, following the communion service: Mennonite Church (MC), [[Conservative Mennonite Conference|Conservative Mennonite Church]], [[Old Order Amish]], [[Fellowship of Evangelical Churches|Evangelical Mennonites]], [[Evangelical Mennonite Conference (Kleine Gemeinde)|Evangelical Mennonites]] ([[Kleine Gemeinde|Kleine Gemeinde]]), [[Reformed Mennonite Church|Reformed Mennonites]], [[Mennonite Brethren in Christ|Mennonite Brethren in Christ]], [[United Missionary Church|United Missionary Church]], [[Krimmer Mennonite Brethren Publications Committee|Krimmer Mennonite Brethren]], [[Church of God in Christ, Mennonite (CGC)|Church of God in Christ Mennonites]]. Among the acculturated groups, the practice has declined since the 1950s. The [[Mennonite Brethren Church|Mennonite Brethren]] formerly universally observed the ordinance, but  in the [[United States of America|United States]] in the 1950s the number was 85-90 percent of the congregations, while in [[Canada|Canada]] only a minority do so. Among the General Conference Mennonites only a small minority of the congregations practice feetwashing, depending upon the background of each congregation. A study by [[Pannabecker, Samuel Floyd (1896-1977)|S. F. Pannabecker]] in 1929 showed that of 107 [[General Conference Mennonite Church (GCM)|General Conference Mennonites]] congregations in the United States, 23 encouraged it. Of the 23, the [[Western District Conference (Mennonite Church USA)|Western District]] had 10, the [[Northern District Conference (General Conference Mennonite Church)|Northern District]] 8. Since then the number has decreased. An official conference study in 1943 showed that then 9 congregations made it obligatory, while 14 encouraged it. The Evangelical Mennonite Brethren, who formerly practiced it universally, have almost completely dropped it. The [[Lower Skippack Mennonite Church (Skippack, Pennsylvania, USA)|Lower Skippack Mennonite Church]] ([[Johnson Mennonites|Johnson Mennonite]]) withdrew from the [[Eastern District Conference (Mennonite Church USA)|Eastern District]] Conference (GCM) in 1861 because it observed feetwashing, while the conference refused to make it mandatory. The Evangelical Mennonites and the Mennonite Brethren in Fernheim Colony, Paraguay, also practice feetwashing.
  
 
It was traditional in the Mennonite Church (MC) and related groups to have a collection for the alms fund or charity fund in connection with the feetwashing service. Usually the contributions are placed in the collection plate by the members individually upon completion of the feetwashing ceremony.
 
It was traditional in the Mennonite Church (MC) and related groups to have a collection for the alms fund or charity fund in connection with the feetwashing service. Usually the contributions are placed in the collection plate by the members individually upon completion of the feetwashing ceremony.

Revision as of 16:56, 5 October 2013

Feetwashing, also called the "washing of the saints' feet," was in the 1950s observed as an ordinance by most Mennonites in the world. It was customarily based on the express command and example of Jesus, who washed His disciples' feet at the Last Supper (John 13:1-17), and on the statement by Paul (1 Timothy 5:9, 10) that having washed the saints' feet was a qualification for a widow's acceptance into the church widows' group. Rarely has the Old Testament practice of washing the feet of visitors as an act of hospitality toward strangers (Genesis 18:4; Genesis 19:2; Genesis 24:32; Genesis 43:24; Judges 19:21; 1 Samuel 25:40, 41) been used to support the practice, except in the early days in Holland, when the practice in some groups was limited to washing the feet of visiting elders and ministers or even of laymen as a sign of affectionate recognition. The most common practice has been and still is to observe the ordinance immediately following the communion service. In the Franconia Conference of the Mennonite Church (MC), where the ordinance was long out of practice, it was observed at the preparatory service on the day preceding communion. Since most congregations that observed it in the 1950s celebrated the communion twice a year, in the spring and fall, feetwashing also came twice a year.

Feetwashing.
Source: Mennonite Archives of Ontario slide collection

The most common mode of the observance is as follows: After the communion service is completed, one of the ministers or deacons reads and comments on John 13:1-17. Basins, usually small wooden or metal tubs, with warm water and towels have meanwhile been provided in sufficient quantity to permit a fairly rapid observance. These are placed, either in the front of the church or in the "amen" corners, and in the "ante-rooms," or in some cases in the rows between the benches. The sexes then wash (more properly rinse or lightly touch with water) feet separately in pairs, concluding with the greeting of the holy kiss and a "God bless you." In some localities towels are furnished in the form of short aprons to be tied by cords around the waist, in presumed imitation of Jesus "girding himself," though most commonly ordinary towels are used. In some congregations the practice is not pair-washing but rowwashing, in which case each person washes the feet of his right-hand neighbor in turn in a continuous chain (United Missionary Church, some General Conference Mennonite congregations). In the Church of God in Christ Mennonite group the ministers wash each other's feet first, and then wash the feet of all the brethren in turn, the ministers' wives doing the same for the sisters.

Although the interpretation of the ordinance may vary, it is always held to be symbolical of a spiritual lesson, and is never considered to have any religious value per se, or to be a "good work." The most common interpretation is that it teaches humility and equality. Often the lesson of service is included along with the other meanings. In some instances it has been and is observed as a symbol of the daily sanctification which is needed by the Christian as he comes into contact with sin and temptation.

Among the North American Mennonite groups the observance varies. The following groups practiced it universally in the 1950s, following the communion service: Mennonite Church (MC), Conservative Mennonite Church, Old Order Amish, Evangelical Mennonites, Evangelical Mennonites (Kleine Gemeinde), Reformed Mennonites, Mennonite Brethren in Christ, United Missionary Church, Krimmer Mennonite Brethren, Church of God in Christ Mennonites. Among the acculturated groups, the practice has declined since the 1950s. The Mennonite Brethren formerly universally observed the ordinance, but  in the United States in the 1950s the number was 85-90 percent of the congregations, while in Canada only a minority do so. Among the General Conference Mennonites only a small minority of the congregations practice feetwashing, depending upon the background of each congregation. A study by S. F. Pannabecker in 1929 showed that of 107 General Conference Mennonites congregations in the United States, 23 encouraged it. Of the 23, the Western District had 10, the Northern District 8. Since then the number has decreased. An official conference study in 1943 showed that then 9 congregations made it obligatory, while 14 encouraged it. The Evangelical Mennonite Brethren, who formerly practiced it universally, have almost completely dropped it. The Lower Skippack Mennonite Church (Johnson Mennonite) withdrew from the Eastern District Conference (GCM) in 1861 because it observed feetwashing, while the conference refused to make it mandatory. The Evangelical Mennonites and the Mennonite Brethren in Fernheim Colony, Paraguay, also practice feetwashing.

It was traditional in the Mennonite Church (MC) and related groups to have a collection for the alms fund or charity fund in connection with the feetwashing service. Usually the contributions are placed in the collection plate by the members individually upon completion of the feetwashing ceremony.

The History of the Ordinance: Pre-Reformation Times

In the time of Jesus it was customary for the host to make provision for the washing of the feet of guests (Luke 7:44-46), but without religious significance. Jesus gave the rite religious significance and told His disciples, "Ye also ought to wash one another's feet. For I have given you an example, that ye should do as I have done to you" (John 13:14, 15). Paul's report in I Corinthians 11 concerning the observance of the communion does not mention feetwashing, but this is no absolute proof that it was not practiced in Corinth. The widows' washing of "the saints' feet" (I Timothy 5:10) is clearly a rite performed only for church members, but no indication is given of when or how often it was to be done. Apparently the widows had a special office or function in the church which included this duty. The implication is that they washed the feet of others, possibly visiting brethren and sisters, rather than practicing a universal mutual ordinance.

Tertullian (145-220) of North Africa in his De Corona is the first Church Father to indicate that feetwashing was practiced in his time, but he gives no clue as to by whom or how. Ambrose of Milan (340-97) states that it was not the practice of the Roman Church, but endorses it as a symbol of sanctification. Augustine mentions it as being rejected by some. Knight (p. 816) says flatly that feetwashing always remained "a purely local peculiarity, introduced at an early date into some parts of the Catholic Church, but never universal." Among the monks in particular, the hospitality custom of feetwashing was widely practiced, and often in the name of Christ, but not as a universal ordinance of the church. For the monks the observance was often intended to express humility. St. Benedict's Rule (A.D. 529) for the Benedictine Order prescribed hospitality feetwashing in addition to a communal feetwashing for humility.

The ordinance of feetwashing persisted down through the Middle Ages, with varied interpretations and applications, more prevalent in the East than in the West. The Roman Church finally observed the practice only as a part of the liturgical festivities of the Holy Week (Maundy Thursday), not as a sacrament, while the Greek Church recognized it as a sacrament, but seldom practiced it. When practiced outside the monastery, it was gradually taken away from the laity and made a pompous ceremony for state officials and clergy. It was frequently observed at coronations of kings and emperors, and installation of popes and archbishops. As late as the 18th century it was a common feature of Maundy Thursday in European Courts, and there are references to it in Bavaria and Austria as late as 1912. Monastic feetwashing is still practiced in both Roman and Greek churches.

The Albigenses and Waldenses, two medieval sects which arose in Southern France in the 11th and 12th centuries, apparently observed feetwashing as a religious rite. The Albigenses observed it following the communion service. Among the Waldenses it was the custom to wash the feet of visiting ministers, but there is no evidence of the practice of the ordinance by the members. The Bohemian Brethren or Hussites also practiced it, at least in the 16th century. The ordinance was not introduced into the new Reformation state churches, but it was adopted by the Anabaptists.

Anabaptist-Mennonite Practice

From the beginning (1525-35) some Anabaptists practiced feetwashing, but it was not universal. It was most common in Holland and the related or descendant groups in Northwest Germany, West and East Prussia, and Russia. It was not practiced by the Swiss Brethren or Hutterites, nor by the 16th-century Anabaptists in South and Central Germany, with rare exceptions. Balthasar Hubmaier (d. 1528) practiced feetwashing at least once in his early (1525) Anabaptist congregation at Waldshut, but does not mention the ordinance in any of his writings. Sebastian Franck in 1531 (Chronica) mentions the practice as observed among some of the Swiss Brethren. William Gay claims (in an unpublished M.A. thesis of 1947 at Columbia University), though without giving documentary proof, "Among the various Anabaptist sects which sprang up all over Western Europe early in the 16th century.... footwashing as a sacramental act of communal humility was practiced almost universally at one time or another. The rite fitted in well with their tendency toward communalism, their Biblical fundamentalism, and their emphasis on self-effacing equalitarianism among the members. Often the ceremony was done in connection with a 'complete' observance of the Last Supper, with the agape and the communion itself following mutual feetwashing segregated according to sex."

If the practice was prevalent at the beginning in Switzerland and South Germany (and there is no proof of this), it must have died out very soon. There is no mention of it in the Schleitheim Confession (1527) or the Peter Riedemann Hutterite confession (1545) or in any other known source except in the writings of Pilgram Marpeck (ca. 1495-1556). Marpeck's great book of ca. 1542 (Verantwortung) makes repeated mention of feetwashing as a Christian ordinance on a par with other ordinances. The first edition of the Ausbund (n.p., 1564) contains a hymn of 25 stanzas (No. 42 in the 1742 first American edition, pp. 692-700) for use at the observance of the ordinance, still used by the Old Order Amish.

Wappler (Thuringen, 129) reports a case of feetwashing observed among the Thuringian Anabaptists. Bullinger claims there was a group called "Apostolic" Anabaptists who practiced feetwashing. This is possibly the ultimate source of a statement by E. Daniel Colberg which names an "apostolic" Anabaptist sect, "also called footwashers, who had as their ancestor Matthew Servatus" (Servaes?). Colberg adds, "modern Anabaptists are almost all footwashers as Joh. Hoornbeek has shown from their writings," probably meaning the Mennonites in North Germany and Holland.

Menno Simons (1496-1561) mentions the practice twice in his Complete Writings, but only as a hospitable practice and not as a church ordinance. However, his colleague, Dirk Philips (1504-68), gives detailed teaching on feetwashing as an ordinance in his Enchiridion of 1564 (English edition, Elkhart, 1910, pp. 388-90). His treatment reveals careful and serious thought and exhorts vigorously to its practice. There is nothing like this treatment in any other 16th-century Anabaptist writing. It was practiced in general by the Dutch Mennonites in the 16th and early 17th centuries.

The first direct evidence that feetwashing was practiced as a general ordinance in Holland is found at the time of the division of the Danziger Old Flemish ca. 1635 from the Groningen Old Flemish. The Groningen group required the observance in connection with the communion service, while the Danzigers required it only for visiting elders who came from other districts to administer baptism. and communion. For these the ordinance was to be observed in the house in which they were guests.

Out of the 19 confessions of faith produced by European Anabaptists and Mennonites from 1527 to 1874, 12 speak of the ordinance of feetwashing as a Christian practice, while 9 omit it altogether. The first one to mention it (Dutch Waterlander Confession of 1577) indicates that it is to be done for visitors from a distance, particularly refugees, but is not prescribed as a church ordinance for a worship service. The same is true for the Concept of Cologne (1591), the Twisck 33 Articles of about 1615, and the George Hansen Flemish Confession of 1678 (Danzig area). All the other seven which mention it (Olive Branch of 1627 in Holland, Dordrecht 18 Articles of 1632, Jan Centsen of 1630 in Holland, the first Prussian confession of 1660, the Prussian confession of G. Wiebe of 1792, and the confession adopted in Russia in 1874 by the Mennonite Brethren) treat it as a general ordinance of the church. The Cornelis Ris' Dutch Confession of 1773 does not mention it, probably because it was already dying out in Holland. The widely used Elbing-Waldeck catechism of 1778 includes it, as does the Russian Mennonite catechism of 1870.

The Alsatian congregations which adopted the Dordrecht Confession in 1660 were probably the channel for the adoption of the same confession with its feetwashing article by the Amish schismatic group which originated 1693-97 in Switzerland. The Amish have ever since been fully committed to feetwashing and in fact were distinguished from the other Mennonites of Switzerland, France, the Palatinate, and South Germany by it, since the latter did not practice it. The Northwest German Mennonites, being closely related to the Dutch Mennonites, followed them both in the observance earlier and in discarding it in the 18th and 19th centuries.

The decline of the practice among the European Mennonites who had earlier practiced it had set in by the 17th century in Holland. N. van der Zijpp supplies the following account of the history of the practice in Holland.

"While in course of time the practice among the Waterlanders soon fell into decline -- it is not mentioned in the ordinances of the Waterlander churches of 1581 -- it was maintained for some time, though not after 1640, by the Frisian, Flemish, and High German congregations. (In the Hamburg congregation under Dutch influence the question arose in 1628 whether feetwashing should be maintained or not; see Inv. Arch. Amst. 1, 576.) But among the conservative Old Flemish and Old Frisians in the 17th century it was again more earnestly practiced. Among them, and also among the Jan Jacobsgezinden and other Fijne Mennisten, it became a church practice observed in connection with the Lord's Supper. So it was still in 1741, when Simon F. Rues visited several Dutch churches among the Groningen Old Flemish (Rues, 53 f.). (A pictorial illustration of feetwashing as practiced in the Groningen Old Flemish congregation of Zaandam is found in Schijn's Geschiedenis of 1743.)

"In this same way feetwashing was performed publicly in the meeting,' as Rues says, among the Old Frisians and also among the Swiss Mennonites who had immigrated to Holland about 1711. The Swiss in Holland practiced it until 1805. Most Old Frisians had abandoned it by 1770, and most Groningen Old Flemish by 1800, though in some of their congregations it was performed until 1815.

"Among the Danzig Old Flemish Mennonites footwashing was not practiced in the meetinghouse in connection with the Lord's Supper, but in the older hospitable form, i.e., to a visiting preacher or elder. The ceremony was performed at his arrival, or in the evening, the host washing the guest's feet in the room in which the guest lodged. It was also done to new members who had come from other places (Rues, 19). The practice was continued among this group until about 1780, when the last Danziger Old Flemish congregation died out. In the 19th century feetwashing in the old form (to visiting elders) was performed only in four Dutch congregations: Giethoorn, Ameland, Aalsmeer, and Balk. Since 1854 no footwashing has been practiced in Holland."

Feetwashing died out among the French and South German Mennonites of Amish background much more slowly than elsewhere. The last observance in Luxembourg was in 1939. There are still five congregations in France which practice it: Birkenhof, Diesen, Haute-Marne, Meuse, and Montbeliard.

Clarence Hiebert (S.T.B. Thesis, Biblical Seminary, 1954) comments upon the decline of feetwashing in Europe as follows: "The decline of this practice was due largely to secularization and compromising influences in the church. Along with the loss of this practice European Mennonitism has gradually lost almost all beliefs that were once distinctive to them. In America, footwashing was rigidly observed by most Mennonite groups, the form and mode being more uniform than it ever was in Europe." Hiebert speculates further as to the causes for the decline, suggesting five reasons.

"1. The ridiculing of the peculiar beliefs of the Mennonites and their emphasis on the 'fringe doctrines' rather than the cardinal beliefs stimulated them to question some of their literalistic practices. Many abandoned this practice as a result of re-examination of their beliefs, in favor of the more cardinal emphases.

"2. The literal interpretation of the Johannine footwashing narrative had never been satisfactory to all. The spiritual concept came to be emphasized as being sufficient without the external act.

"3. The influence of the larger denominations upon the Mennonites played no little part in bringing about compromises in their traditional beliefs. This was especially true in Holland, where the Reformed and the Mennonite churches often united.

"4. The liberal tendencies which began in the 18th century, especially through the Mennonite Seminary in Amsterdam, were influential in changing the entire church.

"5. Because the more conservative element was constantly emigrating in the 19th century from Germany and France in search of religious freedom, the liberalizing tendencies gained the upper hand.

"Other reasons could be listed, but these are the cardinal factors and suggest the trend of European Mennonitism."

Russia

Here, according to P. M. Friesen (Brüderschaft, 40, 82), the Flemish group observed the ordinance in connection with the communion, while the stricter of the Frisians practiced the observance in the home of the minister when a guest minister arrived. Specifically the Gnadenfeld and Alexanderwohl congregations were among those that observed the ordinance at communion. Among Bernhard Harder's (1832-84) poems, published in 1888 at Hamburg as Geistliche Lieder, was one written to be sung at the feetwashing service. Its dominant emphasis is that of cleansing from "sin which collects like dust" in men's souls. All the schismatic groups in Russia, Kleine Gemeinde (1812), Mennonite Brethren (1860), and Krimmer Mennonite Brethren (1869), continued the practice. The observance was brought to North America by all these groups and the Mennonite congregations as well which had practiced it there. The Swiss-Alsatian Amish in Volhynia also brought the practice with them.

North America

The first documentary evidence of the observance of feetwashing in North America is found in a document of ca. 1775 relating to the Martin Boehm case, in which the leaders of the Lancaster Conference specifically refer to the ordinance of feetwashing as commanded by Christ to show humility. John Herr, the founder of the Reformed Mennonite Church in 1812, describes the Lancaster Mennonite group as having declined greatly and states "The washing of feet, if not rejected, was at least practically omitted for many years" (Funk, 13). By contrast Funk (p. 114) quotes a letter of an aged member in 1878 who specifically recalled that Bishop Jacob Hostetler's (bishop 1831-65) charge to the bishops he ordained included the administration of feetwashing The Lancaster Conference hymnal, Unpartheyisches Gesangbuch (1804), contained one hymn (p. 117) to be used during feetwashing and the first English Mennonite hymnal, A collection of Psalms, hymns and spiritual songs (Mountain Valley, Va., 1847), contained three (pp. 288-91). A pamphlet published in 1859 at Berlin, Ont., written by Ulrich Steiner (?), was devoted exclusively to feetwashing (Fusswaschung und Deutung derselben).

The strange deviation in the Franconia Conference from this general practice of the Mennonite Church is unexplainable. The Dordrecht Confession, first printed in English in 1712 for the Germantown group, and adopted in 1725 by a conference of all the congregations in America at that time (printed at Philadelphia in 1727), has a specific and strict article on feetwashing. Yet J. C. Wenger reports, "It appears that until a generation or so ago what is now the Skippack bishop district was the only one which observed Feet-Washing" (Franconia, 34). This is supported by the fact that the Franconia Conference hymnal Die Kleine Geistliche Harfe (1803), in contrast to the Lancaster hymnal, had no feetwashing hymn. Only gradually did the observance spread after 1900, particularly when Henry S. Bower, a preacher, and the noted bishop Andrew Mack put his influence behind it. "As late as 1917," says Wenger (p. 105), the conference admonished the ministers "to teach the subject of feetwashing more earnestly, so that it may be more generally observed." But there are some facts on the other side. The letter of Andreas Ziegler et al. to Holland in 1773, written on behalf of the Franconia Conference, inquires "whether you keep up the observance of feetwashing" (Franconia, 401), thus implying the observance in Franconia at that time.

It is interesting to note that the Oberholtzer group, which broke away from the Franconia Conference in 1847, according to Hiebert, for a time after their initial organization continued the practice of feetwashing in connection with the communion service. In 1851, four years later, they decided the observance should not be compulsory, and in 1853 it was made an optional practice with complete freedom in the local congregation. Finally, in 1855 it was no longer recognized as a church ceremony. A spiritual interpretation of the passage (John 13) was agreed upon at the 1859 conference. The Lower Skippack congregation, which intended to continue the observance of the ordinance, thus came into conflict with the conference. Henry G. Johnson, the bishop, was declared out of order by the conference in 1859, and formally excommunicated in 1861 taking most of the congregation with him. Lower Skippack has continued as an independent congregation to this day. J. C. Wenger (Franconia, 360) suggests that the conference may have originally adopted feetwashing to meet the demands of Johnson who was a strong advocate of it, but without any connection with a general practice by the body as a whole.

Feetwashing has been introduced into the foreign mission fields of the American Mennonite groups in accord with the constituency.

The following other North American denominations are among those which in 1956 still observed feetwashing as a standard ordinance: Church of the Brethren, Brethren Church, Grace Brethren Church, Brethren in Christ, and a number of minor Baptist bodies. The Moravian Brethren practiced it until 1818 when it was discontinued by act of the Moravian Synod.

There is no uniformity in the writing of the term "feetwashing." Five other forms often used are: foot washing, footwashing, foot-washing, feet washing, and feet-washing. The initial letters "F" and "W" are sometimes also written in capitals.

Much of the material of this article has been drawn (and sometimes directly quoted) from Clarence Hiebert's thorough unpublished S.T.A.B. thesis of 1954 at the Biblical Seminary in New York, entitled "The History of the ordinance of feet-washing in the Mennonite Churches with a survey of the pre-Reformation evidences of this practice." Daniel Graber's unpublished paper (1952) at the Mennonite Biblical Seminary in Chicago, entitled "The history of the ordinance of feet-washing as observed by the Mennonites," was also of service. The items in the following bibliography were all (with one exception) taken from the very extensive bibliographical section of Hiebert's paper.


Feetwashing. Students of the New Testament are aware that the Lord's command to "wash one another's feet" John 13:14) is one of the clearest in the New Testament sources. It is reinforced with the words: "I have set you an example: you are to do as I have done for you" John 13:15). For this reason, it is not surprising that the practice made its way into the Anabaptist movement. At the same time, as Harold Bender points out in in the above article, largely based on research by Clarence Hiebert, it was not uniformly practiced among the Mennonites and this is still the case. Biblical scholars have done more research into the history of the practice and the meaning thereof. indeed H. S. Bender's book on the church, while it does not speak about the practice as such, invokes it when he refers to the two great symbols of the church as the cross and the towel. For Bender the towel symbolizes service: "The Christ who took the towel to wash His disciple's feet is our example in service" (p. 96). With a renewal of physical contacts in church there has been some movement to institute or keep feetwashing, but by and large it seems to be suffering from neglect even as a deeper understanding of its symbolism is emerging. At least it is no longer practiced just because of historical reasons and greater efforts are being made to explain the action. There is little evidence that efforts are being made to keep the practice even as it is clear that views of service and models of service are much discussed.

The Confession of faith in a Mennonite perspective (1995) includes an article on feetwashing. The 1975 Mennonite Brethren Confession no longer includes such a reference.

Bibliography

Books

Bergsrasser, P. Baptism and Feetwashing. Philadelphia, 1896.

Brunk, George R. Ready Scriptural Reasons. Scottdale, PA: Mennonite Publishing House, 1926.

Colberg, E. Daniel. Das Platonisch-Hermetische Christentum. Leipzig, 1710.

Dale, A. W. The Synod of Elvira and Christian Life in the Fourth Century. London, 1882.

"Foot-washing" in McClintock and Strong's Cyclopedia of Biblical, Theological and Ecclesiastical Literature. N.Y., 1891.

Funk, John F. The Mennonite Church and Her Accusers. Elkhart, IN: Mennonite Publishing Co., 1878.

Gay, William . "The Origin and Historical Practice of Foot-Washing as a Religious Rite in the Christian Church." MA thesis, Columbia University under the Faculty of the Union Theological Seminary in N.Y., 1947.

Horsch, John. Mennonites in Europe. Scottdale, PA: Mennonite Publishing House, 1942.

Kauffman, Daniel. Doctrines of the Bible. Scottdale, PA: Mennonite Publishing House,1949.

Knight, G. A. F."Feetwashing." Encyclopedia of Religion and Ethics 5. N.Y., 1912: 814-23.

Kurtz, D. W. "Washing of Feet." International Standard Bible Encyclopedia 5. Chicago, 1915.

Malvy, A. "Lavement des Pieds." Dictionnaire de Theologie Catholique 9. Paris, 1926: cols. 16-36.

Mack, Alexander. Appendix to The Refuted Anabaptist. Ephrata, 1788.

Pannabecker, S. F. "The Development of the General Conference of the Mennonite Church of North America in the American Environment." PhD dissertation: Yale University, 1914.

Rues, S. F. Tegenwoordige Staet. Amsterdam 1745.

Schijn, H. Geschiedenis dier Christenen welke . . . Mennoniten genaamd worden 1. Amsterdam, 1743.

Smoker, George. "Permanent Principles Implicit in the Ancient Christian Rite of Feetwashing."  STB. thesis: Biblical Seminary in New York, 1940.

Thurston, Herbert. "Washing of Feet and Hands." Catholic Encyclopedia 15. N.Y., 1913.

Ursinus, Johann. Historisch- und Theologischer Bericht vom Unterschied der Religionen Heutiges Tags auf Erden und Welches der Waare Allein-Seligmachende Glaube Sey. Nürnberg, 1663.

Wenger, J. C.  History of the Mennonites of the Franconia Conference. Telford, PA, 1938.

Yoder, C. F. God's Means of Grace. Elgin, IL, 1908.

Bender, Harold S. These Are My People. Scottdale, PA: Herald Press, 1962: 96.

Periodicals, Articles, and Pamphlets

Bacon, B. W. "The Sacrament of Footwashing." Expository Times 43 (1931-32): 218-21.

Berkey, E. J. "Is Feet-Washing a Command?" Ttract, Scottdale, ca. 1905.

"Feet-Washing." Tract, Scottdale, ca. 1910.

Coffman, S. F. "Christian Ordinances: Feet Washing." "Christian Monitor 44 (Scottdale, 1952): 206-7, 240-41, 245, 276-77.

Fleming, Walter. "The Religious and Hospitable Rite of Feet Washing." Sewanee Review (January 1908).

Janzen, Jacob H. Fusswaschung und Abendmahl. Winnipeg, n.d..

S[teiner], U.[lrich]. Fusswaschung und Deutung derselben. Berlin, ON, 1859.

Mennonitisches Lexikon II, 22-24.

Additional Information

Confession of Faith in Mennonite Perspective


Author(s) Harold S. Bender
William Klassen
Date Published 1989

Cite This Article

MLA style

Bender, Harold S. and William Klassen. "Feetwashing." Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. 1989. Web. 18 Apr 2024. https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Feetwashing&oldid=102209.

APA style

Bender, Harold S. and William Klassen. (1989). Feetwashing. Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. Retrieved 18 April 2024, from https://gameo.org/index.php?title=Feetwashing&oldid=102209.




Hpbuttns.png

Adapted by permission of Herald Press, Harrisonburg, Virginia, from Mennonite Encyclopedia, Vol. 2, pp. 347-351; vol. 5, p. 295. All rights reserved.


©1996-2024 by the Global Anabaptist Mennonite Encyclopedia Online. All rights reserved.